Compostings

Icon

A blog about a small, backyard vegetable garden.

Tomato Controversy: Pruning – A Sucker Born Every Minute

Depending upon who you ask (and they’ll often tell you that it further depends upon what variety you are growing and how you are supporting them) tomatoes either don’t need or do need pruning.

Let’s get down to what I think works according to the general consensus of whatever science there is.

  1. Pruning will reduce your total fruit yield, but what is yielded will be larger.
  2. Pruning is not required, but it in many cases and in many zones will improve the plant’s odds of avoiding fungus invasions and other disease. Overcrowded plants can create little humidor environments with moist air stuck inside and limited air circulation! Keep in mind that removing too many suckers etc. can actually hurt your fruit. The leaves create little sun umbrellas that help eliminate sunscald. The more sun and heat that your zone gets, the better it is to leave more leaves.
  3. Focus your real pruning on your indeterminate tomatoes. Smaller determinate (bush) tomatoes will have their burst yields reduced if you prune them. From time to time, I prune away smaller lower branches or suckers from determinate plants like Roma, but it’s just to keep things off of the soil. For semi determinate varieties like Celebrity, prune just a little – wait for flowers to emerge and prune off the suckers (we’ll define that in a second) below the first flower cluster, but not the sucker just below it – skip one in other words.
  4. Wait until the plants have settled nicely and have grown a bit. For my bigger indeterminates I’ll wait until the first few suckers (seriously.. we’re going to define that in a second) have developed into branches/vines and my plant is filling in the cage or the stake.
  5. I’m gonna get you sucka! Prune the suckers. Okay, so moving on… Alright, alright. The definition of suckers. You’ll see it defined something like – “the little shoots that form in the crotch (yes.. crotch) of a branch and main stem”. Run your finger up a tomato plant, starting at the base of the stem – the main vine. You’ll hit a branch soon. Look right where the main vine and branch join and you may see a sucker – a new branch shooting up at about a 45 degree angle. Left to its own devices, it will soon turn into another vine and will even grow fruit. Leave a few on to grow and “pinch” off the others. That’s pruning.

Experimentation is probably the key here. Some people swear by pruning others swear while pruning (like me.. man that’s a lot bending over) and others swear that pruning is a waste of time. See what works for you. Do it all the way! Do it half way (a little thing called “missouri” pruning where you only pinch off the tip of the sucker), but do something for goodness sake!

Filed under: tomatoes , , , , , ,

14 Responses

  1. Nancy Bond says:

    Your title is ingenious, by the way. :) Thanks for the tips on pruning! Or not.

  2. ourfriendben says:

    Had to chime in and congratulate you on the great title! Kudos to you (and the post was good too, by the way).

  3. sjones71 says:

    Thanks for the title compliments! Silliness prevails!

  4. Daphne Gould says:

    I’ve tagged you on my blog. If you want to play, head over there.

  5. James says:

    Great advice on the pruning! I also prune when the tomato is about to eat the house and its occupants…

  6. sjones71 says:

    This is good advice James! Any time the plant makes a move toward you or your children or if it is eyeing the pets… prune with reckless abandon.

  7. asonomagarden says:

    We had the sucker debate this year too. Scott’s done it in the past but didn’t really feel like it was worth the effort. Maybe next year we’ll leave one go free and on another one prune and see who does better.

  8. Mias says:

    never tried growing toms before.. so when i read that i have remove those suckers, I prune ruthlessly.. and discover that it is a never ending job… but the vines sure gets fatter after the pruning. lots of flower but no toms fruit yet.

  9. savagegirl says:

    My husband and I had a fight over which stem was the sucker. He said it is the one to the left of the “crotch” at the 90 degree angle. I said the suckling is the one in the middle! I am right but won’t tell him that.

  10. sjones71 says:

    The sucker is always shrouded in mystery! My experience – the wife is usually right!

  11. rowena says:

    I can see where this tomato pruning controversy could possibly replace my enthusiasm for d-i-y clipping of my westie’s coat. I think it’ll be the better for all as an improperly pruned tomato plant is less unbecoming than a dog with a bad haircut! Great article with photos to boot!

  12. Chuck Bartok says:

    I am glad to see someone else discuss the pruning Controversy. We raised our family with a 20 acre Truck Farm and tomatoes were a major Income source, so we grow for Yield.

    Not everyone agrees with our pruning practice, but that is waht makes Gardening so exciting.

    I also posted your link on our Blog

    As mentioned on you other Blog,

    This year I have recorded our Tomato Venture for the past 13 weeks.
    You and you readers may enjoy visiting the Videos and commenting. Appreciate Ratings also.

    Growing Tomatoes for Health and Wealth

    We also started a blog.
    Not as professional but having Fun

    http://www.2growtomatoes.info
    Comments appreciated

  13. Roger says:

    Driven a bit dingy, no doubt, by trying to keep up with pruning my tomato plants, I tried eating a sucker the other day. It tasted like lettuce and seemed to have no ill effect on me. Would it be unwise to harvest suckers and add them routinely to salads?

    I’ve read many discussions about pruning suckers, but none about pruning new tomato flowers. By pruning flowers can you focus a plant’s energies on speeding the growth of the fruit it is already working on?

    Thanks in advance for any wisdom!

    Well, I’ve never eaten the suckers. Tomatoes are nightshade plants and poisonous. Yuck. For pruning flowers, a lot of people do that as fruit is setting. I definitely prune off flowers from the early plants. A lot of times (especially for transplants) they’ve grown flowers too soon – before the plants have a chance to set up in the soil.

Leave a Reply