I’m not much for conspiracy theories. I don’t often rail against the government or big companies. Perhaps it’s because I work for a big company!
But I am trying to be very careful about which agriculture companies I support. Local is good. Usually. Sometimes. Unless you live local to Monsanto!
These days it is harder and harder to figure out who is behind the stuff you think it’s safe to get behind. We are in the garden catalog season and I look carefully through all of them. I’ve got my steady seed suppliers, but sometimes I want to try something new. So, when the catalog from cooksgarden.com came in, I decided to see if I could track down who they are. Perhaps they are a fine upstanding company. Perhaps they are a front for some vile, dark creatures from Monsanto.
So, how can you do this? How can you figure out who actually owns “Happy Organic Land O’ Farmers Pastoral Beauty And Niceness”? A few ways.
1. Check their website. Sometimes they will tell you who they are. When they do, don’t stop checking. Follow the trail further. When they don’t, at least try and find an address beyond a p.o. box. In the case of cooksgarden.com, the website did not give me any information on who actually owned them. Spidey senses tingling, I kept looking.
2. Hoovers.com is hooked into Dun & Bradstreet. You can often find company information here, but it’s much more applicable to publicly-traded entities and you frequently have to pay to get more information. But give it a shot. I gave it a shot for cooksgarden.com (aka The Cooks Garden) and came up empty.
3. The good ol’ government! Almost every state (except New Jersey) requires any business to register. And just about every state has an online interface to allow you to search a business. And this link from the Consumer Advisory Council provides links to every state. Incredibly handy. Since I knew that Cooksgarden.com was in Warminster, PA (Warminster, Warminster.. sounds familiar for some reason) I clicked through to PA and there it was!
(Yes as my programs show I was playing World Of Warcraft.)
What I learned was that The Cook’s Garden is actually a “fictitious name”. That sounds ominous, but it’s fairly standard. It really means that they are “doing business as” (dba) and many individuals do this. And many corporations do too. It lets you run a business under a different name without having to set up a new legal entity. No big deal. Usually.
In this case, The Cook’s Garaden of Warminster, PA is actually owned by Burpee. Good to know. Now I can decide if I’m okay with that. (Repeating the search process will show how Burpee has changed hands. George Ball Jr. runs the show.)
By the way, The Garden of Eatin blog has a compiled list of seed companies that have links to Monsanto. Super easy to check the list here.
At the end of the day you may or may not agree with how I would assess the merits of one company over another. Let’s not quibble about that! Do your own checking on your own companies. I’ve got a pretty thick anti-Monsanto streak in me and you may not. (But you should.) The point is, check these companies out. Be careful. Be vigilant. Be supportive of the companies and their parents, and their holdings, and their LLCs, DBAs once you have all the facts.
Happy hunting!
Update: I wanted to add a late-breaking link from Daphne’s Dandelions. She’s using Fedco Seeds and they apparently use a identification system on their seeds that lets you know where the seeds are coming from. There’s even a category for Monsanto – with only one variety linked to them.
Might as well also link to my seed suppliers.
Another Update:
Ali from Henbogle commented on the confusion around Johnny’s Selected seeds. I think it’s worth pointing out here in the body of the post that they are not owned by Monsanto. They are family owned and partially employee owned – on the way to being wholly employee owned. Here is the link from Johnny’s that explains it all.
Update: The original post indicated that Burpee was linked to Seminis and Monsanto. This is not the case.
I’m new to gardening, and I’m interested in heirloom seeds (seemed like the best way to avoid monsanto). Someone told me about rareseeds.com which is all heirlooms, so I’m going to try it this year. I’m so new (and a bit young) that I’ve never even seen a seed catalog! đŸ™‚
That’s great Lauren! Heirloom seeds are a great route (even though the definition is often a bit loose), but you can’t go wrong if you do a little research. Not sure where you live, but it’s often a great tactic to at least find a seed supplier who tests stuff for your region. Still, you can’t go wrong with seedsavers exchange at seedsavers.org. Fully monsanto free and dedicated to preserving some genetic diversity. you’ll find plenty of heirloom stuff there. for me (I live in Connecticut) i get most of my seeds from pinetree seeds in maine at superseeds.com. And definitely get yourself on some catalog lists! You don’t have to order from the catalog (i always do the order online) but it’s a great way to figure out what you want to plant. Good luck! Send photos of your garden…
THe super seed your talking about is GMO..
I never get seeds from Cooks Garden, but of course at this white-covered time of year I do appreciate their catalog for their green porn…especially their multicolored lettuces. However even during my rather cursory perusal, I did notice a couple of “Our own variety, from Burpee’s” in its pages. Bingo!
Great for you to go down such a rabbit hole to find who owns them, though. Whew.
Now see El… that’s just too easy. Reading the catalog to find out who owns the company?
Burpees I heard are affiliated with Monsanto
Johnny’s Selected Seeds of Winslow, Maine is not affiliated with Monsanto. Johnny’s began as a privately owned company and is now employee-owned. They conduct field trials on their gorgeous farm in Albion, Maine. Johnny’s develops many of their own varieties which is great for northeast gardeners. Johnny’s does sell Seminis varieties, but is actively working to replace them with others.
Check out Founder Rob Johnston’s response to the rumor that Johnny’s is affiliated with Monsanto here: http://www.johnnyseeds.com/t-ownership.aspx
I’m a big Johnny’s fan — they are an honest and ethically run company which is really taking a hit from this rumor. Please help spread the truth.
Thanks Ali. Good to know. I personally think there’s a difference between a supplier who sells some seeds from Seminis/Monsanto vs. a company that is in some way owned by them. I have heard the confusion around Johnny’s Selected Seeds before and I’m glad that Rob Johnston is working to eliminate the Seminis taint completely.
Actually, it seems Johnny Seeds does do business with Monsanto via Seminis … take a look here….
http://us.seminis.com/products/hg_dealer.asp
Johnnyseeds is listed right on their webpaage.
Having moved in September, within Western CT, to a home with a pre-built, fenced in garden, I’m really eager to get back to veggie gardening. We received our first catalog, Burpee, last week and I went searching for heirloom seeds. Obviously the definition is different than what I thought. One of their heirlooms was introduced in 1950. Hmm.
I thought I was going to have to do some major research to find good seed companies, but I’m going to be lazy and go with those that you’ve been using. Now, if I were being SUPER lazy, I’d ask what seeds you were planting this year and start there. đŸ˜‰
I love being past the holidays with time freed up to plot and plan. Thanks.
Laziness is a virtue Sonya! I think that the heirloom definition is pretty loose, but even one from 1950 is probably pretty good. To me, the heirloom is a preserved variety that is open pollinated. For those of us in CT, choosing Pinetree seeds in Maine is a good choice – so is Johnny’s.
I’ll be putting my garden plan up soon, but it’s pretty simple. I am going less diverse this year and just focusing on the stuff I like to grow and the family likes to eat. It will mostly be peas, beans, broccoli, garlic, greens (lettuces, spinach, chard), cucumbers and if I’m productive I’ll build a separate potato patch.
Very interesting article! I’m glad to see more ideas on how to find out where our seeds are coming from. And thanks for visiting my blog!
Anybody checking here should also go check gina’s myskinnygarden post. Great blog post on heirlooms.
Good tip for finding out who owns these smaller seed companies. I talked to someone from Burpee recently and was surprised at them being open about owning Cook’s, here I thought it was a big secret.
I’ve been following your Burpee story Mr. Brown Thumb. I’m wondering how common it is for the label/picture to be wrong for any seed company.
Monsanto/Seminis Seeds
*PINETREE (Superseeds) buys some seeds from Monsanto/Seminis. The list of the varieties are listed below:
SEMINIS GARDEN VARIETIES
44. PACKMAN BROCCOLI
48 EARLY DIVIDEND BROCCOLI
51 BUBBLES (DISC)
70 DANVERS HALF LONG CARROT
83 MINUTEMAN
8402 CHEDDAR CAULIFLOWER
133 SWEETER YET CUCUMBER
137 SWEET SUCCESS CUCUMBER
138 EARLY TRIUMPH CUCUMBER
142 SALAD BUSH CUCUMBER
151 DUSKY EGGPLANT
158 LAVENDER TOUCH EGGPLANT
20501 SIMPSON ELITE LETTUCE
215 RED SAILS LETTUCE
224 ALASKA MELON
22601 AMBROSIA MELON
230 FASTBREAK MELON
237 ANNIE OAKLEY II OKRA
239 CAJUN DELIGHT OKRA
257 MR BIG PEA
27101 BIG BERTHA SW PEPPER
274 RED BEAUTY
279 FOOLED YOU PEPPER
281 HOLY MOLE PEPPER
293 SPIRIT PUMPKIN
300 ORANGE SMOOTHIE PUMPKIN
340 AMBASSADOR SUM SQUASH
342 GLODBAR SUM SQUASH
34601 SCALLOPINI SUM SQUASH
347 SUNDANCE SUM SQUASH
348 GREYZINI SUM SQUASH
34801 PAPAYA PEAR SUM SQUASH
349 GOLDRUSH SUM SQUASH
350 LOLITA SUM SQUASH
362 TABLE ACE WINTER SQUASH
371 EARLY BUTTERNUT WINTER SQUASH
38001 AUTUMN CUP WINTER SQUASH
38202 HI-BETA GOLD WINTER SQUASH
389 ALPINE STRAWBERRY WHITE
390 BEEFMASTER TOMATO
391 BETTER BOY TOMATO
393 GOLDEN GIRL TOMATO
395 CLUSTER GRANDE TOMATO
400 CELEBRITY TOMATO
407 SUN SUGAR TOMATO
41401 POLISH LINGUISA TOMATO
446 SWEET DIANE WATERMELON
W120 STRAIGHT N NARROW BEAN
W130 COOL BREEZE IMP CUCUMBER
W479 THAI NIPPON TAKA HOT PEPPER
Pingback: Grow Your Food to Know Your Food | Living Non-GMO : The Non-GMO project
Ball has nothing to do with Monsanto. They compete with them.
Thanks
Lee
Thanks Lee. It seems it is a common misunderstanding. This is a very old post, but I will go in and correct that reference.
Pingback: Happy Planting: Grow a Non-GMO Garden! – The Non-GMO Project
Pingback: Growing My Non-GMO Garden – The Non-GMO Project